I know a lot of this is borrowed from other sources, but this is really well-done. I love it. :)
I don't like Deadm(Au5), but this is amazing. For one of your first dubstep songs, it's super cool, which makes me super jealous. Keep it up. I'd enjoy hearing more of this from you. Should have more votes. :) 5/5 10/10
This is a pretty decent mix. You have some interesting sounds in there. The percussion is definitely the right stuff for classic industrial. :) There are melodies that don't really work or don't really go anywhere, and this song is more of a collage of individual melody parts, rather than a cohesive whole which builds up and breaks down. It's not bad, just needs more of a flow. OR, this song would work extremely well if it just had some good vocals (I'm thinking Velvet Acid Christ-type vocals). :D If you get the chance, I'd love to hear a vocal mix! :)
ps. You should totally review one of my songs. :D (if you do, please try to be constructive)
4/5, 7/10, and a kiss *mwah*
It's more like a journey, so I didn't think it needed a cohesive melody. There are distinctive parts, but I wanted it to have diversity and not have a pop structure. If one were to animate this, different scenes would unfold as the song progressed and the journey would not start where it began.
This is an excellent piece. I can feel the emotions in the piece, and the melodies work very well. While the drums are effective where necessary, they also tend to be a bit generic. They fit well in this scenario, but in the realms of another song, they might not sound as good. Like I stated on the other song I reviewed, the ambiance and presence of the song is very impressive. Keep it up. :)
I like this. It's a good mix of simplicity and complexity. I like the instruments you used. They feel very full, and are very effective for the atmosphere you are trying to create. The ambiance is great; I only wish for a little more structure. :)
That was awesome. Kind of a Heaven/Hell type mix. The beginning is totally awesome. Then it gets into the experimental kind of glitch/noise stuff. Parts of that are just awesome, while other parts aren't so hot, but all in all this song is AWESOME. Can't wait until you finish it. I don't know why the score is so low. Oh, I remember: People on Newgrounds only listen to MAINSTREAM music. They have no idea about experimental music AT ALL. Stupid peoples.
Reminds me of Silent Hill. Awesome job. =)
Very Mike Shinoda-ish sounding.
I agree with IDReaper. It does remind me of Linkin Park. Which isn't a bad thing. Awesome. The only bad thing is that it's so short.
that it is... i'm working on a longer version :D
Sorry. My personal opinion.
In this one I had added more build-up and background, yet the grudge against midi and my songs was evident enough.
Maybe I should say thanks for not voting, since you'd vote it really low. My guess is you are a professional who cannot acknowledge a melody or rhythm, or have heard many great songs that make mine seem like crap.
That said, I am clearly stating this piece does not deserve a 3.
But then again,
Your Personal Opinion.
Very, very messy.
It's really messy and it doesn't flow. The harmonies are off, and again, basic MIDI instruments. I'm sorry, but I don't really like it. Luckily for you, I'm not voting for them, just reviewing, otherwise your ratings would go down a lot.
I'd used the same program while making this.
i see why you say it's messy, and i can tell you why. it's the beat. even though it's not off, it's very irregular, and i was aiming for the randomness.
I do say that the harmony wasn't off at all, the beat just made everything seem to choppy.
Also, I don't expect you to like it. Just a fair review of the music and my experience. thanks again for your input.
newgrounds.com — Your #1 online entertainment & artist community! All your base are belong to us.